I have no idea how to label the entry when I review one of the old epic miniseries like Shogun or Roots. Anyway, Shogun.
Um... Well, let me put it this way. It's an American movie, about Japanese history, with a white guy thrown in, made in 1980.
Oy vey...
Given that, it's not nearly as bad as it could be. Nonetheless, there is much unintentional amusement.
Language: Even the most rudimentary knowledge of the Japanese language will provide you with giggling opportunities. Now, I'm always fond of a movie using "Ikura desu ka" for "How are you?", which I think I heard somewhere in the first chapter -- although perhaps that character was asking the hero how much he costs. ("ikura desu ka" = "how much is it". To the best of my extremely meager knowledge, there is no direct open-ended equivalent to the English "how are you" and the closest is "Ogenki desu ka" = "Are you well?")
However, it is hard to beat in the first chapter when the hero is still in captivity and the not-nice local second-in-command and the evil Jesuit (which is largely a redundant statement in this movie) interpreter come in where the hero is sleeping, and the Jesuit insists that "you must get up right now and greet Omi-san with 'Konnichiwa'." Konnichiwa?! Good afternoon? Apparently the reason it's so urgent he get up is because he's slept until 3 pm.
Names: Mariko, Fujiko, Kiku, and many more, not even so much as an "O" honorific prefix floating around among the women until we meet Lady Ochiba -- and I suspect hers was a fluke. These are modern names that came into popularity in the early part of the 20th century. Using them here is the equivalent of setting an movie in Queen Elizabeth I's court and naming her ladies in waiting Keisha, Madison, and Taylor.
Stereotypes: The makers just can't keep their stereotypes straight. My favorite here is that if a married woman is so much as alone with a man other than her husband, she can be executed -- but it's perfectly OK for her to take a bath with one because the Japanese have no body taboos.
The magic burn cream gets high points on my list, too, because I know that knowledge of Western medicine was highly valued later in the 19th century because it was much more effective than Japanese medicine at the time. And we still don't have that kind of magic burn treatment even today.
Timing: Either Blackthorne becomes the second foreigner in all of history to be granted the title of samurai within just a few months of arriving in Japan, or even after several years of full immersion in Japanese culture he is only able to speak the most basic of sentences.
I also personally find it flaming hilarious that Blackthorne is made "Hatamoto" before he is made a member of the samurai class. Hatamoto in that time period was the title for a samurai in the direct service of a lord (rather than further down the hierarchy). In other words, he's given one of the highest possible ranks for a samurai before he's made a samurai.
Karma: For those interested in such things, there are a multitude of opportunities to shout "that's not karma!" in the last couple episodes. What they are describing as "karma" could maybe come under the term "dharma", but mostly they're just talking about good old-fashioned Western destiny. It is absolutely not karma.
Basic Plot: We are at the tail-end of the warring states period. We've got about 10 hours of movie time here. We can spend it watching a fictionalized Tokugawa Ieyasu fight to gain power over all Japan, or we can spend it watching a frankly rather lackluster romance. Romance it is! :P
So, is it worth watching? Um... It's probably not worth 10 hours of your life. But, there is Toshiro Mifune. ::squees and claps:: If you want the full Mifune filmography, you almost have to. Or, if you like laughing at anachronisms and can pick them out of a movie set in 16th/17th century Japan, go nuts. That's largely outside my knowledge, so I've only touched the tip of the iceberg. (Although, what is the deal with all the hakama having white ties no matter what the main fabric? I have never seen or heard of such a thing before. Is it a historical bit I didn't know, or did they have to special-order wrong hakama?) Or, if you don't know anything at all about Japan and don't give a crap, and like long drawn-out lackluster romances with occasional long stretches of dialog in a language you can't understand, this is the flick for you!
Showing posts with label TV series. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TV series. Show all posts
Sunday, March 14, 2010
Thursday, November 26, 2009
Babylon 5 DVDs - the technical issues
Babylon 5 was an awesome series. If you're a sci fi person and you haven't seen it, you should. If you liked Star Trek DS9, you'll like Bab 5 even more (and, um, that's not a coincidence. ^_^;)
However, the DVD releases have some technical issues. The way I hear it, Straczynski was perhaps a little too farsighted. He realized that 16:9 proportion HDTVs were coming and that syndicated reruns and video sets of TV series were going to have a market and acted accordingly, and IMHO that actually makes the current release worse than it would have been if he'd been as shortsighted as everyone else in the mid 90s.
Three problem areas: Live action shots, CG shots, and live action w/ CG special effects. (Yeah, that pretty much covers everything. Hang with me here, though.)
Live action shots have the least problems. Straczynski realized that widescreen TVs were coming and so taped the live action portions in widescreen on high resolution movie film. However, shots were still framed for the ubiquitous 4:3 TVs at the time. So at best, there's a lot of basically empty space on the sides of every wide shot. Close-ups are worse, though. A lot of his closeups are so close to show facial expressions that the tops of heads are cut off. This was fine on a 4:3 where the framing made it obvious (or more accurately, less jarring) that this is why the heads are chopped off. But in widescreen, you've got someone's hairline cut off and tons of empty space in the sides of the shot. It looks for all the world like they've made a mock widescreen by cutting off the tops and bottoms of a 4:3 shot.
(Even knowing scenes were actually filmed widescreen, I'm still convinced the Sci Fi channel did just cut off portions of some of the later episodes during their first widescreen showing, because the contents of Cartagia's desk were really quite important to that scene. But that's beside the point.)
Bigger problem is the CG scenes. They were NOT originally rendered in high resolution 16:9. The idea was that by the time 16:9 HDTVs became commonplace, computer rendering technology would be much better, so they would just re-render the scenes for widescreen with the better technology. I can see where at the time that seemed like a good idea, especially given how slow rendering was at the time (and probably still is, really). Looking back, I can also see how what actually happened was almost inevitable.
See, there were a few important questions that were not answered when they made this decision. Will the future technology be backwards compatible with our files? Will our files be high resolution enough to look good with the future technology? And, the one that bit them in the ass, do we have a robust storage system for all of our files?
When you're doing CGI, you aren't working with a single file. Usually each object, or at least each major object, is in a separate file for easier reuse and lower file sizes. Well, they've lost some of the models; they just don't have them any more.
So, they CAN'T re-render the CG scenes, because they don't have some of the important files. They don't have good archival copies of the CG scenes, because "we're just going to re-render those". All they have is the lower resolution NTSC format.
So, they're mixing the excellent image quality of the widescreen live-action scenes with the absolutely awful quality of the NTSC CG scenes that have not been stored well. To be perfectly honest, the switching back and forth from great quality to horrible gives me a headache to watch.
And, of course, to widescreen the CG shots they do have to chop off bits of the screen.
The worst to me, though, are scenes where CG effects are used in live action shots. They can't redo the CG effects. Sometimes they can recomposite the original effects over the better widescreen footage, which doesn't always looks so good. Sometimes they can't even do that and the entire image quality drops, which gives the effect of "Whoa, Delenn, you went all fuzzy all of a sudden". And whenever they do a composite shot, they have to chop off bits to maintain the widescreen ratio, because they don't have the sides of the shot in the special effects footage.
Lots of fans are unhappy with the image quality on the DVDs, and of course everyone has different ideas of how it could be fixed. Me personally, assuming it's possible, I'd rather have just the original 4:3 format shows, with the associated lower image quality in the live action shots but consistent quality throughout. It's the jump in quality between scenes depending on whether there's CG or not that gives me headaches. And frankly, I'd rather have the full shots of the CG scenes than the extra unessential side areas of the live shots that we get when converting to 16:9.
However, the DVD releases have some technical issues. The way I hear it, Straczynski was perhaps a little too farsighted. He realized that 16:9 proportion HDTVs were coming and that syndicated reruns and video sets of TV series were going to have a market and acted accordingly, and IMHO that actually makes the current release worse than it would have been if he'd been as shortsighted as everyone else in the mid 90s.
Three problem areas: Live action shots, CG shots, and live action w/ CG special effects. (Yeah, that pretty much covers everything. Hang with me here, though.)
Live action shots have the least problems. Straczynski realized that widescreen TVs were coming and so taped the live action portions in widescreen on high resolution movie film. However, shots were still framed for the ubiquitous 4:3 TVs at the time. So at best, there's a lot of basically empty space on the sides of every wide shot. Close-ups are worse, though. A lot of his closeups are so close to show facial expressions that the tops of heads are cut off. This was fine on a 4:3 where the framing made it obvious (or more accurately, less jarring) that this is why the heads are chopped off. But in widescreen, you've got someone's hairline cut off and tons of empty space in the sides of the shot. It looks for all the world like they've made a mock widescreen by cutting off the tops and bottoms of a 4:3 shot.
(Even knowing scenes were actually filmed widescreen, I'm still convinced the Sci Fi channel did just cut off portions of some of the later episodes during their first widescreen showing, because the contents of Cartagia's desk were really quite important to that scene. But that's beside the point.)
Bigger problem is the CG scenes. They were NOT originally rendered in high resolution 16:9. The idea was that by the time 16:9 HDTVs became commonplace, computer rendering technology would be much better, so they would just re-render the scenes for widescreen with the better technology. I can see where at the time that seemed like a good idea, especially given how slow rendering was at the time (and probably still is, really). Looking back, I can also see how what actually happened was almost inevitable.
See, there were a few important questions that were not answered when they made this decision. Will the future technology be backwards compatible with our files? Will our files be high resolution enough to look good with the future technology? And, the one that bit them in the ass, do we have a robust storage system for all of our files?
When you're doing CGI, you aren't working with a single file. Usually each object, or at least each major object, is in a separate file for easier reuse and lower file sizes. Well, they've lost some of the models; they just don't have them any more.
So, they CAN'T re-render the CG scenes, because they don't have some of the important files. They don't have good archival copies of the CG scenes, because "we're just going to re-render those". All they have is the lower resolution NTSC format.
So, they're mixing the excellent image quality of the widescreen live-action scenes with the absolutely awful quality of the NTSC CG scenes that have not been stored well. To be perfectly honest, the switching back and forth from great quality to horrible gives me a headache to watch.
And, of course, to widescreen the CG shots they do have to chop off bits of the screen.
The worst to me, though, are scenes where CG effects are used in live action shots. They can't redo the CG effects. Sometimes they can recomposite the original effects over the better widescreen footage, which doesn't always looks so good. Sometimes they can't even do that and the entire image quality drops, which gives the effect of "Whoa, Delenn, you went all fuzzy all of a sudden". And whenever they do a composite shot, they have to chop off bits to maintain the widescreen ratio, because they don't have the sides of the shot in the special effects footage.
Lots of fans are unhappy with the image quality on the DVDs, and of course everyone has different ideas of how it could be fixed. Me personally, assuming it's possible, I'd rather have just the original 4:3 format shows, with the associated lower image quality in the live action shots but consistent quality throughout. It's the jump in quality between scenes depending on whether there's CG or not that gives me headaches. And frankly, I'd rather have the full shots of the CG scenes than the extra unessential side areas of the live shots that we get when converting to 16:9.
Wednesday, November 26, 2008
When Engineers Watch Cartoons
I've got a box set of Batman: The Animated Series DVDs, and I need to get another because I'm almost done. The series has survived the test of time well; it's still a pretty fun watch most of the time.
However, as an engineer, the episode "The Clock King" had me laughing my ass off, so I am going to make a terribly geeky entry about it. (With spoilers, of course.)
First scenario, the Clock King locks Batman in a bank vault with a high speed pump that is pumping the oxygen out out of the room. Ooh, this is impressive, isn't it? Especially since the pump isn't connected to anything. It's just sitting there in a box. We even move the box, just to prove it. As near as I can tell, it's diabolically pumping air out of the bank vault and into... the bank vault. Huh.
But it gets better. Batman can't just disable the pump, because the housing is rigged with a vibration-triggered bomb!
Let me say that again. There is a vibration triggered bomb, on a pump. Pumps don't shake at all, do they? Especially not when they're pumping something compressible like air, right?
Clock King, dude, forget the revenge scheme. You need to go patent that vibration-free, connection-free pump thing!
But we're not done. The next one is common to lots of cartoons, though. So, we're in a huge gear works, and we jam up one of the gear meshes.
Now of course when you do this, you never just jam thing up, and yet you also never just destroy the obstacle, strip a gear of all of its teeth, or twist a shaft in half. There are absolutely no weak links in cartoon gear works. No, instead the entire gearworks, every little bitty piece, always rips itself apart in an incredibly catastrophic and often explosive manner.
And yet, it's still fun to watch. I love being a nerd.
However, as an engineer, the episode "The Clock King" had me laughing my ass off, so I am going to make a terribly geeky entry about it. (With spoilers, of course.)
First scenario, the Clock King locks Batman in a bank vault with a high speed pump that is pumping the oxygen out out of the room. Ooh, this is impressive, isn't it? Especially since the pump isn't connected to anything. It's just sitting there in a box. We even move the box, just to prove it. As near as I can tell, it's diabolically pumping air out of the bank vault and into... the bank vault. Huh.
But it gets better. Batman can't just disable the pump, because the housing is rigged with a vibration-triggered bomb!
Let me say that again. There is a vibration triggered bomb, on a pump. Pumps don't shake at all, do they? Especially not when they're pumping something compressible like air, right?
Clock King, dude, forget the revenge scheme. You need to go patent that vibration-free, connection-free pump thing!
But we're not done. The next one is common to lots of cartoons, though. So, we're in a huge gear works, and we jam up one of the gear meshes.
Now of course when you do this, you never just jam thing up, and yet you also never just destroy the obstacle, strip a gear of all of its teeth, or twist a shaft in half. There are absolutely no weak links in cartoon gear works. No, instead the entire gearworks, every little bitty piece, always rips itself apart in an incredibly catastrophic and often explosive manner.
And yet, it's still fun to watch. I love being a nerd.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
